JOHANNESBURG - The Progressive Health Forum wants Limpopo Health MEC Dr Phophi Ramathuba dismissed.
Ramathuba was recorded berating a foreign national in a Bela Bela hospital.
The organisation says the MEC's actions contradict both ethical and constitutional guidelines.
The Forum's Professor Alex van den Heever says that as a senior government official, there must be consequences.
"There so many things that are wrong, one is the Hippocratic oath, but she was not in that situation as a doctor and she wasn't there in a position as a doctor and also in a position to be able to see patients or to even speak to them or to challenge their conduct in any way.
"She in many respects was a private person when she was standing there before that patient and if I went into a hospital and started speaking to a patient like that, you know I should be arrested on the spot. It's completely inappropriate," he said.
"So she's got no basis for acting as if though she's got a role in berating that patient in any level.
"But you can't get away from the fact that she is a senior representative of government and that disproportionate power relation and one that can influence other staff members is a serious one and that means that she really needs to be held to account for it."