South Africa's Retirement Crisis Begins Long Before Retirement
South Africa has a retirement problem that begins decades before people reach retirement age. The warning is not simply that workers are saving too little. It is that the economic circumstances shaping their working lives are making long-term financial security increasingly difficult to achieve.
The Alexforbes Member Insights 2026 report illustrates the scale of the challenge. Only 10% of contributing members in the retirement funds administered by Alexforbes are projected to replace at least 75% of their final pensionable salary when they retire. Although this represents an improvement from 6% in 2021, the
findings suggest that the overwhelming majority of contributing members remain financially unprepared for retirement.
The question is no longer simply whether South Africans understand the importance of saving. It is whether the country's economic realities allow enough people to act on that understanding.
The Difference Between Having A Job And Building Wealth
Employment provides an income, but it does not automatically create financial security. Workers must divide their earnings between immediate expenses and obligations that may be decades away. Housing, transport, food, education and family responsibilities all compete with retirement contributions.
This creates a difficult contradiction. Retirement planning rewards consistency, while financial pressure frequently demands flexibility. A worker may understand the value of preserving retirement savings but still need money to manage an immediate household emergency.
The Alexforbes research found that the average member contribution rate was 11.2% of salary, below the 15% benchmark used in its long-term retirement illustrations.
The significance extends beyond the contribution gap. Money not invested today also loses the opportunity to accumulate returns over time. For workers whose financial circumstances delay retirement saving, catching up can become progressively more expensive.
Time Is An Asset That Cannot Be Recovered
Consider two workers contributing the same percentage of their salaries towards retirement. One begins at the start of a career. The other begins 20 years later.
Under the assumptions used by AlexForbes, saving 15% of salary for 40 years could provide retirement income equivalent to 75% of final pensionable salary. Saving the same percentage for only 20 years produces a projected replacement ratio of 27%.
To reach the 75% target within that shorter period, the required contribution rises to 41% of salary.
These are illustrative projections rather than guaranteed outcomes, but their implication is clear. Delaying retirement contributions creates a financial burden that higher earnings later in life may not easily overcome.
It also reveals a structural inequality. Workers who enter stable employment early have more time to accumulate savings than those who experience prolonged unemployment, interrupted careers or irregular income.
When Today's Emergency Becomes Tomorrow's Shortfall
South Africa's two-pot retirement system creates another important tension. Access to a portion of retirement savings can provide financial relief when households face unexpected expenses. However, repeated withdrawals reduce the money available to remain invested for retirement.
The Alexforbes illustration discussed on Number of the Day shows how annual withdrawals could reduce a projected 75% retirement-income replacement ratio to 51%.
That does not mean access to savings is inherently harmful. The deeper problem arises when retirement funds become a substitute for emergency savings or a response to persistent financial insecurity.
A sustainable retirement system must therefore address both sides of the problem: preserving money for the future while acknowledging the financial pressures workers face today.
Retirement Security Cannot Be An Afterthought
Retirement planning needs to become part of financial decision-making from the beginning of working life. Starting early, reviewing contribution levels, preserving investments and seeking appropriate financial advice can all improve retirement prospects.
But individuals cannot carry the entire burden. Employers, financial institutions and policymakers also have roles in making retirement planning accessible, understandable and sustainable.
A country cannot measure financial wellbeing only by how much its people earn while working. It must also consider whether those earnings allow them to live with independence and dignity once work ends.
The real retirement crisis is not simply that South Africans are failing to prepare for the future. It is that too many are struggling to afford that preparation in the present.
References
· Moneyweb: Alexforbes data shows 10% of retirees now on track · BusinessTech: Retirement shock for South Africans · Alexforbes: Financial planning and advice
· eNCA, Number of the Day, 15 October 2026.
Catch up on all Number of the Day episodes here: https://www.enca.com/number-day-podcast