Number Of The Day | 17% | 16 November 2026

When telecoms companies merge, will customers share the gains?

Telkom's share price rose by as much as 17% amid renewed talks about a possible acquisition by MTN. For investors, the prospect of a buyer for the entire company creates an immediate question about value. For mobile customers, however, a different question matters: would a bigger operator deliver better service, or leave people with fewer meaningful alternatives?

That distinction is the heart of the debate about consolidation in telecommunications. A transaction can make commercial sense for the companies involved and still require a much harder public-interest examination. South Africa's mobile market

already includes powerful operators, and removing an independent competitor would change the choices available to consumers.

The promise of scale

Telecommunications businesses depend on expensive networks. Coverage, capacity and reliability require continuing investment, while infrastructure can take years to build and maintain. Combining operations might reduce duplication and help an enlarged business direct resources towards improving its network. Telkom also brings more than a mobile subscriber base: its history as a fixed-line operator gives its infrastructure an additional strategic dimension.

But efficiencies are not the same as consumer benefits. A merger might lower costs for the combined company without producing cheaper data, better coverage or more responsive service. Those outcomes depend on what management does with the savings and, crucially, on whether customers can take their business elsewhere when promises are not met.

Why the smaller rival matters

Competition is not simply a contest between the two biggest networks. The presence of another credible operator can influence pricing, packages and the urgency with which market leaders respond to customers. Even when a rival is smaller, the ability to win dissatisfied subscribers gives the larger companies a reason to keep improving.

That pressure can weaken if customers have fewer credible choices. On the other hand, an operator that cannot invest adequately may struggle to provide meaningful competition, regardless of how many brands remain in the market. The relevant test is therefore not a simplistic preference for more companies or fewer companies. It is whether the structure left behind would support sustained competition and investment.

A decision beyond shareholders

A proposed MTN–Telkom deal would face scrutiny from competition authorities and communications regulator ICASA. Telkom's ownership structure introduces another layer: government remains a substantial shareholder, alongside a stake held by the Government Employees Pension Fund. Any proposed transaction must navigate commercial interests as well as the implications of changing control over an important communications business.

Those hurdles are not administrative footnotes. They are the mechanism through which questions about market power, infrastructure and the public interest receive attention beyond the boardroom. Nor should a dramatic share-price increase be mistaken for evidence that a takeover is certain to happen.

The strongest argument for consolidation would be one that survives a consumer test. If a larger network can invest more and compete more effectively, the benefits should become visible in the prices people pay, the reliability they experience and the alternatives still available to them. Until those outcomes are clear, a 17% market reaction says far more about investor expectations than it does about the future of South African mobile services.

References

eNCA, Number of the Day, 16 November 2026 (Gareth Edwards and Francis Herd).

You May Also Like