The Ballot Decides The Seats. The Negotiating Table Decides The Government.
South Africa's local elections have exposed a difficult democratic question: how should political parties turn fragmented results into legitimate, accountable municipal governments?
South Africans can spend months debating which party deserves to win an election, only to discover that the more consequential contest begins after the ballots have been counted. A party can secure the largest share of support in a municipality and still find itself unable to govern. Another can finish some distance behind, yet acquire considerable influence over who becomes mayor.
That is the paradox of coalition politics. Elections establish the distribution of political power, but negotiations determine how that power is exercised. For residents waiting for functioning infrastructure, reliable services and accountable leadership, the distinction is anything but academic.
When winning is not enough
The aftermath of the 2026 local government elections has brought this reality into focus. The ANC's declining support, the DA's electoral position and ActionSA's growing significance in coalition negotiations have created a political environment in which no single party can necessarily dictate the outcome.
Johannesburg illustrates the difficulty. The challenge is not simply identifying the largest party, but establishing which combination of parties can command sufficient council support to elect a mayor, pass budgets and sustain the administration.
Every additional coalition partner potentially introduces another set of priorities, demands and disagreements. A governing majority assembled from several parties may be mathematically possible without being politically durable.
This is where election analysis often stops too early. Coalition arithmetic establishes who can govern together. It does not establish whether they can govern effectively.
The difference between a coalition and a government
A coalition agreement is ultimately a framework for sharing political responsibility. It must provide answers to questions that extend far beyond who receives the mayoral chain or which party controls a particular portfolio.
What happens when coalition partners disagree over a budget? Who carries responsibility when service-delivery targets are missed? How will disputes be resolved without repeatedly threatening the administration's survival?
These questions become particularly important in municipalities where voters have already experienced political instability. An agreement that settles the immediate leadership contest but leaves operational responsibilities unclear risks transferring uncertainty from the negotiating table into council chambers.
The most consequential test of a coalition is therefore not whether it survives its first mayoral vote. It is whether it can make difficult decisions consistently enough for the municipality to function.
Do voters still have a say after election day?
Coalition negotiations create another tension: parties may enter agreements with political opponents they campaigned against. Such arrangements can be legitimate within the electoral system, but their legitimacy should not depend solely on whether they meet the legal requirements for forming a majority.
Voters are entitled to understand why a partnership was chosen, what compromises were made and which commitments remain in force.
That is why transparency matters. Publishing the principles and commitments underpinning a coalition would give residents a clearer basis for judging the administration. It would also make it harder for political leaders to shift responsibility when agreements begin to unravel.
Accountability becomes especially difficult when every coalition partner can claim credit for success while blaming someone else for failure.
The real verdict comes after the deal
The results of a local election can reveal public frustration, changing party loyalties and the emergence of new political forces. But those signals are only the beginning of the democratic process.
The decisions made after the election will determine whether political parties treat the result as an opportunity to build workable institutions or simply as another contest over office.
A coalition's true measure will not be the number of signatures on its founding agreement. It will be the quality of its decisions, the clarity of its accountability and the services that residents experience.
South Africans have already decided how their councils should be composed. The next question is whether the politicians negotiating in their name can turn those results into governments that work.
Catch up on all SA Explained episodes here: https://www.enca.com/sa-explained-podcast
References
- SA Explained — Naledi Moleo in conversation with Wayne Sussman, recorded 17 November 2026.