File: A cross outside a church. AFP/Lakruwan Wanniarachchi
JOHANNESBURG - The release of controversial televangelist Timothy Omotoso from custody has reignited public debate around the regulation of religious leaders in South Africa.
Omotoso was released after a magistrate ruled that the Department of Home Affairs failed to follow proper arrest procedures over the weekend.
His detention came just weeks after he was acquitted of 32 serious charges, including rape, human trafficking, and racketeering.
While the legal battle continues to cast a shadow over his name, a broader question has emerged: Should South Africa begin vetting pastors and religious leaders, especially those who lead mega-churches?
This issue gained even more traction after MK Party secretary-general Floyd Shivambu was seen visiting Malawi to meet Shepherd Bushiri, a self-proclaimed prophet and fugitive wanted in South Africa on charges including rape and fraud.
On the South African Morning, viewers were asked whether religious leaders like Omotoso and Bushiri should face more scrutiny before setting up churches in the country.
The overwhelming response: Yes, but it’s complicated.
“Opening a church should come with restrictions,” wrote Tsholofelo Sayda Nowalaza. “Much like opening a club or tavern, you should need a licence.”
Others echoed that sentiment, saying the lack of regulation allows some pastors to exploit vulnerable followers.
“They know South Africans believe in miracles,” commented Casanova NdiDarkandlovely Mate, “and they take advantage of that.”
Lucas Lehoko suggested that churches follow structured systems similar to the Roman Catholic Church, which imposes stricter internal oversight.
But not everyone agreed.
Some, like Ndala Mukamba Jupsy, argued that foreign pastors are unfairly targeted once they gain influence. “Why is it always the successful ones? Suddenly there’s a rape case. We know how this works,” he said.
Others questioned whether the core issue lies in religion or broader state failure.
“It’s not just about vetting. Corruption is the real problem,” said Landile Vika. “The church is losing its meaning because the system is broken.”
A few commenters drew even starker lines. “Jesus Christ instituted one church - the Catholic Church,” wrote MichaelMGJ. “Everything else is a business.”
And for those who still believe in the spiritual calling of modern-day pastors, the regulation debate feels misplaced.
“You don’t vote for someone to be a prophet,” wrote Major’s Son Tapiwa. “It’s a calling from God, not a government job.”