Tribunal rules against restaurant over automatic 10% service charge

JOHANNESBURG - The National Consumer Tribunal has ruled against Pretoria restaurant TriBeCa Standard over its practice of automatically adding a 10% service charge to customers’ bills.

The establishment described the service charge as discretionary on its menu. However, customers who were unhappy with the service had to approach management and specifically request that the charge be removed from their bills.

An investigation by the National Consumer Commission found that the restaurant was processing approximately 200 service charge transactions every day.

ALSO READ | NCC issues recall of ESR HaloLock wireless power banks

The Tribunal ruled that the practice was unfair and contravened the Consumer Protection Act, which protects consumers against unfair business practices.

According to the Tribunal, restaurants are permitted to accept tips from customers, but the decision to leave a tip must rest entirely with the customer.

“A genuinely voluntary gratuity is one that the consumer freely elects to pay. It is not an amount automatically added to a bill and removed only if the consumer challenges it. In this case, the service charge was not genuinely voluntary, and reflecting it on the invoice did not remedy the failure to include the additional charge for specific services in the full price,” the Tribunal said.

This means restaurants cannot automatically impose a service charge on customers' bills, even if the charge is described as discretionary. 

The Tribunal said while restaurants can accept tips, but customers must choose to give them.

You May Also Like